Domain Adaptation for Face Anti-Spoofing Based on Dual Disentanglement and Liveness Feature Progressive Alignment

Feng Jun; Shi Yichen; Gao Yuhao; He Jingjing; Yu Zitong

doi:10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330251

Journal of Computer Research and Development > 2023 > 60(8): 1727-1739. > DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330251

Feng Jun, Shi Yichen, Gao Yuhao, He Jingjing, Yu Zitong. Domain Adaptation for Face Anti-Spoofing Based on Dual Disentanglement and Liveness Feature Progressive Alignment[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2023, 60(8): 1727-1739. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330251

Citation:

PDF (2018 KB)

Domain Adaptation for Face Anti-Spoofing Based on Dual Disentanglement and Liveness Feature Progressive Alignment

1.
School of Information Science and Technology, Shijiazhuang Tiedao University, Shijiazhuang 050043
2.
Great Bay University, Dongguan, Guangdong 523000

Funds: This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (61772070, 61972267) and the Key Projects of Science and Technology Research in Colleges and Universities of Hebei Province (ZD2021333).

More Information

Author Bio:
Feng Jun: born in 1971. PhD, professor. Member of CCF. Her main research interests include computer vision, machine learning, and complex network analysis

Shi Yichen: born in 1998. Master. His main research interests include face anti-spoofing and transfer learning

Gao Yuhao: born in 2000. Master candidate. His main research interest includes face anti-spoofing

He Jingjing: born in 2000. Master candidate. Her main research interest includes face anti-spoofing

Yu Zitong: born in 1992. PhD, assistant professor. His main research interests include biometric recognition and multimedia security
Received Date: March 30, 2023
Revised Date: June 15, 2023
Available Online: June 26, 2023

Graphical Abstract

Abstract

Abstract

Although existing face anti-spoofing methods perform well in intra-domain testing, their performance significantly degrades in cross-domain scenarios. Current cross-domain face anti-spoofing methods based on domain adversarial alignment cannot guarantee that the alignment task directly serves the classification task since the alignment and classification networks are independent of each other. We propose a domain adaptation for face anti-spoofing method based on domain invariant liveness features dual disentanglement and progressive adversarial alignment. Firstly, the source domain features are heuristically disentangled into domain specific features and domain invariant features. Then, the gradient of classifier is used to perform a second disentanglement of the live-related and live-unrelated features in the domain invariant features. To alleviate optimization difficulties during training, a curriculum learning method is adopted to progressively align target domain features and the combination of live-related and live-unrelated features, gradually increasing the proportion of live-related features, and enhancing the correlation between the target domain features and face anti-spoofing task. From a causal perspective, we provide an explanation for the liveness alignment domain adaptation. Experimental results on CASIA-MFSD, Idiap Replay-Attack, MSU-MFSD, and OULU-NPU datasets demonstrate that the proposed method achieves the best average HTER value of 22.5% compared with ten existing methods and the current state-of-the-art performance on four evaluation protocols. Especially the HTER values of I-M and O-M evaluation protocols achieve 12.4% and 12.8%, respectively. The proposed method can significantly reduce the error rates of the model in the target domain and has better cross-domain generalization ability.
- face anti-spoofing,
- domain adaptation,
- dual disentanglement,
- domain adversarial progressive alignment,
- curriculum learning

FullText(HTML)

References (51)

References

[1]	Ganin Y, Ustinova E, Ajakan H, et al. Domain-adversarial training of neural networks[J]. The Journal of Machine Learning Research, 2016, 17(1): 1−35
[2]	De F P T, Anjos A, De M J M, et al. LBP-TOP based countermeasure against face spoofing attacks[C] //Proc of the Asian Conf on Computer Vision. Berlin: Springer, 2012: 121−132
[3]	Liu Chengjun, Wechsler H. Gabor feature based classification using the enhanced Fisher linear discriminant model for face recognition[J]. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2002, 11(4): 467−476 doi: 10.1109/TIP.2002.999679
[4]	束鑫,唐慧,杨习贝,等. 基于差分量化局部二值模式的人脸反欺诈算法研究[J]. 计算机研究与发展,2020,57(7):1508−1521 doi: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2020.20190319 Shu Xin, Tang Hui, Yang Xibei, et al. Research on face anti-spoofing algorithm based on DQ_LBP[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2020, 57(7): 1508−1521 (in Chinese) doi: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2020.20190319
[5]	Galbally J, Marcel S, Fierrez J. Image quality assessment for fake biometric detection: Application to iris, fingerprint, and face recognition[J]. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2013, 23(2): 710−724
[6]	Ikeuchi K, Miyazaki D, Tan R T, et al. Separating reflection components of textured surfaces using a single image[J]. Digitally Archiving Cultural Objects, 2008, 6(3): 353−384
[7]	Yu Zitong, Peng Wei, Li Xiaobai, et al. Remote heart rate measurement from highly compressed facial videos: An end-to-end deep learning solution with video enhancement[C] //Proc of the IEEE/CVF Int Conf on Computer Vision. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2019: 151−160
[8]	Li Xiaobai, Komulainen J, Zhao Guoying, et al. Generalized face anti-spoofing by detecting pulse from face videos[C] //Proc of the Int Conf on Pattern Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2016: 4244−4249
[9]	Pan Gang, Sun Lin, Wu Zhaohui, et al. Eyeblink-based anti-spoofing in face recognition from a generic webcamera[C] //Proc of the IEEE 11th Int Conf on Computer Vision. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2007: 1−8
[10]	Pan Gang, Wu Zhaohui, Sun Lin. Liveness detection for face recognition[J]. Recent Advances in Face Recognition, 2008, 9(2): 109−124
[11]	Chingovska I, Yang Jianwei, Lei Zhen, et al. The 2nd competition on counter measures to 2D face spoofing attacks[C] //Proc of the Int Conf on Biometrics. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2013: 1−6
[12]	Boulkenafet Z, Komulainen J, Hadid A. Face anti-spoofing based on color texture analysis[C] //Proc of the IEEE Int Conf on Image Processing. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2015: 2636−2640
[13]	Patel K, Han H, Jain A K. Secure face unlock: Spoof detection on smartphones[J]. IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security, 2016, 11(10): 2268−2283 doi: 10.1109/TIFS.2016.2578288
[14]	Boulkenafet Z, Komulainen J, Hadid A. Face antispoofing using speeded-up robust features and Fisher vector encoding[J]. IEEE Signal Processing Letters, 2016, 24(2): 141−145
[15]	Komulainen J, Hadid A, Pietikäinen M. Context based face anti-spoofing[C] //Proc of the 6th IEEE Int Conf on Biometrics: Theory, Applications and Systems . Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2013: 1−8
[16]	Yang Jianwei, Lei Zhen, Li S Z. Learn convolutional neural network for face anti-spoofing[J]. arXiv preprint, arXiv: 1408.5601, 2014
[17]	Liu Yaojie, Jourabloo A, Liu Xiaoming. Learning deep models for face anti-spoofing: Binary or auxiliary supervision[C] //Proc of the IEEE Conf on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2018: 389−398
[18]	Atoum Y, Liu Yaojie, Jourabloo A, et al. Face anti-spoofing using patch and depth-based CNNs[C] //Proc of the IEEE Int Joint Conf on Biometrics. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2017: 319−328
[19]	Wang Zezheng, Yu Zitong, Zhao Chenxu, et al. Deep spatial gradient and temporal depth learning for face anti-spoofing[C] //Proc of the IEEE/CVF Conf on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2020: 5042−5051
[20]	王宏飞,程鑫,赵祥模,等. 光流与纹理特征融合的人脸活体检测算法[J]. 计算机工程与应用,2022,58(6):170−176 doi: 10.3778/j.issn.1002-8331.2108-0046 Wang Hongfei, Cheng Xin, Zhao Xiangmo, et al. Face liveness detection based on fusional optical flow and texture features[J]. Computer Engineering and Applications, 2022, 58(6): 170−176 (in Chinese) doi: 10.3778/j.issn.1002-8331.2108-0046
[21]	汪亚航,宋晓宁,吴小俊. 结合混合池化的双流人脸活体检测网络[J]. 中国图象图形学报,2020,25(7):1408−1420 Wang Yahang, Song Xiaoning, Wu Xiaojun. Two-stream face spoofing detection network combined with hybrid pooling[J]. Journal of Image and Graphics, 2020, 25(7): 1408−1420 (in Chinese)
[22]	马思源, 郑涵, 郭文. 应用深度光学应变特征图的人脸活体检测[J]. 中国图象图形学报, 2020, 25（3）: 618−628 Ma Siyuan, Zheng Han, Guo Wen. Deep optical strain feature map for face anti-spoofing[J]. Journal of Image and Graphics, 2020, 25(3): 618−628(in Chinese)
[23]	Yu Zitong, Zhao Chenxu, Wang Zezheng, et al. Searching central difference convolutional networks for face anti-spoofing[C] //Proc of the IEEE/CVF Conf on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2020: 5295−5305
[24]	Li Haoliang, Li Wei, Cao Hong, et al. Unsupervised domain adaptation for face anti-spoofing[J]. IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security, 2018, 13(7): 1794−1809 doi: 10.1109/TIFS.2018.2801312
[25]	Gretton A, Borgwardt K M, Rasch M J, et al. A kernel two-sample test[J]. The Journal of Machine Learning Research, 2012, 13(1): 723−773
[26]	Tu Xiaoguang, Zhang Hengsheng, Xie Mei, et al. Deep transfer across domains for face anti-spoofing[J]. Journal of Electronic Imaging, 2019, 28(4): 43001
[27]	翁泽佳,陈静静,姜育刚. 基于域对抗学习的可泛化虚假人脸检测方法研究[J]. 计算机研究与发展,2021,58(7):1476−1489 doi: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2021.20200803 Weng Zejia, Chen Jingjing, Jiang Yugang. On the generalization of face forgery detection with domain adversarial learning[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2021, 58(7): 1476−1489 (in Chinese) doi: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2021.20200803
[28]	Kim Y E, Nam W J, Min K, et al. Style-guided domain adaptation for face presentation attack detection[J]. arXiv preprint, arXiv: 2203.14565, 2022
[29]	Hamblin J, Nikhal K, Riggan B S. Understanding cross domain presentation attack detection for visible face recognition[C] //Proc of the 16th IEEE Int Conf on Automatic Face and Gesture Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2021: 1−8
[30]	Wang Guoqing, Han Hu, Shan Shiguang, et al. Improving cross-database face presentation attack detection via adversarial domain adaptation[C] //Proc of the Int Conf on Biometrics. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2019: 1−8
[31]	El-Din Y S, Moustafa M N, Mahdi H. Adversarial unsupervised domain adaptation guided with deep clustering for face presentation attack detection[J]. arXiv preprint, arXiv: 2102.06864, 2021
[32]	Yang Luyu, Balaji Y, Lim S N, et al. Curriculum manager for source selection in multi-source domain adaptation[C] //Proc of the European Conf on Computer Vision. Berlin: Springer, 2020: 608−624
[33]	Shu Yang, Cao Zhangjie, Long Mingsheng, et al. Transferable curriculum for weakly-supervised domain adaptation[C] //Proc of the AAAI Conf on Artificial Intelligence. Menlo Park, CA: AAAI, 2019, 33(1): 4951−4958
[34]	Gong Chen, Tao Dacheng, Maybank S J, et al. Multi-modal curriculum learning for semi-supervised image classification[J]. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2016, 25(7): 3249−3260 doi: 10.1109/TIP.2016.2563981
[35]	Wang Yiru, Gan Weihao, Yang Jie, et al. Dynamic curriculum learning for imbalanced data classification[C] //Proc of the IEEE/CVF Int Conf on Computer Vision. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2019: 5017−5026
[36]	Cui Shuhao, Jin Xuan, Wang Shuhui, et al. Heuristic domain adaptation[J]. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2020, 33: 7571−7583
[37]	Wei Guoqiang, Lan Culing, Zeng Wenjun, et al. ToAlign: Task-oriented alignment for unsupervised domain adaptation[J]. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2021, 34: 13834−13846
[38]	Selvaraju R R, Cogswell M, Das A, et al. Grad-cam: Visual explanations from deep networks via gradient-based localization[C] //Proc of the IEEE Int Conf on Computer Vision. Los Alamitos, CA: IEEE Computer Society, 2017: 618−626
[39]	Chattopadhay A, Sarkar A, Howlader P, et al. Grad-cam++: Generalized gradient-based visual explanations for deep convolutional networks[C] //Proc of the IEEE Winter Conf on Applications of Computer Vision . Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2018: 839−847
[40]	Bengio Y, Louradour J, Collobert R, et al. Curriculum learning[C] //Proc of the 26th Annual Int Conf on Machine Learning. New York: ACM, 2009: 41−48
[41]	Zhang Zhiwei, Yan Junjie, Liu Sifei, et al. A face antispoofing database with diverse attacks[C] //Proc of the 5th IAPR Int Conf on Biometrics. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2012: 26−31
[42]	Chingovska I, Anjos A, Marcel S. On the effectiveness of local binary patterns in face anti-spoofing[C] //Proc of the Int Conf of Biometrics Special Interest Group. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2012: 1−7
[43]	Wen Di, Han Hu, Jain A K. Face spoof detection with image distortion analysis[J]. IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security, 2015, 10(4): 746−761 doi: 10.1109/TIFS.2015.2400395
[44]	Boulkenafet Z, Komulainen J, Li Lei, et al. OULU-NPU: A mobile face presentation attack database with real-world variations[C] //Proc of the 12th IEEE Int Conf on Automatic Face & Gesture Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2017: 612−618
[45]	Yang Jianwei, Lei Zhen, Yi Dong, et al. Person-specific face antispoofing with subject domain adaptation[J]. IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security, 2015, 10(4): 797−809 doi: 10.1109/TIFS.2015.2403306
[46]	Ghifary M, Kleijn W B, Zhang M, et al. Deep reconstruction classification networks for unsupervised domain adaptation[C] //Proc of the European Conf on Computer Vision. Berlin: Springer, 2016: 597−613
[47]	Tzeng E, Hoffman J, Saenko K, et al. Adversarial discriminative domain adaptation[C] //Proc of the IEEE Conf on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2017: 7167−7176
[48]	Wang Guoqing, Han Hu, Shan Shiguang, et al. Unsupervised adversarial domain adaptation for cross-domain face presentation attack detection[J]. IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security, 2020, 16(7): 56−69
[49]	Hu Lanqing, Kan Meina, Shan Shiguang, et al. Duplex generative adversarial network for unsupervised domain adaptation[C] //Proc of the IEEE Conf on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2018: 1498−1507
[50]	Jourabloo A, Liu Yaojie, Liu Xiaoming. Face de-spoofing: Anti-spoofing via noise modeling[C] //Proc of the European Conf on Computer Vision. Berlin: Springer, 2018: 290−306
[51]	Yang Xiao, Luo Wenhan, Bao Linchao, et al. Face anti-spoofing: Model matters, so does data[C] //Proc of the IEEE/CVF Conf on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE, 2019: 3507−3516

[1]	Li Nan, Ding Yidong, Jiang Haoyu, Niu Jiafei, Yi Ping. Jailbreak Attack for Large Language Models: A Survey[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2024, 61(5): 1156-1181. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330962
[2]	Wang Mengru, Yao Yunzhi, Xi Zekun, Zhang Jintian, Wang Peng, Xu Ziwen, Zhang Ningyu. Safety Analysis of Large Model Content Generation Based on Knowledge Editing[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2024, 61(5): 1143-1155. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330965
[3]	Chen Xuanting, Ye Junjie, Zu Can, Xu Nuo, Gui Tao, Zhang Qi. Robustness of GPT Large Language Models on Natural Language Processing Tasks[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2024, 61(5): 1128-1142. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330801
[4]	Chen Huimin, Liu Zhiyuan, Sun Maosong. The Social Opportunities and Challenges in the Era of Large Language Models[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2024, 61(5): 1094-1103. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.202330700
[5]	Yang Yi, Li Ying, Chen Kai. Vulnerability Detection Methods Based on Natural Language Processing[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2022, 59(12): 2649-2666. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.20210627
[6]	Pan Xuan, Xu Sihan, Cai Xiangrui, Wen Yanlong, Yuan Xiaojie. Survey on Deep Learning Based Natural Language Interface to Database[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2021, 58(9): 1925-1950. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2021.20200209
[7]	Zheng Haibin, Chen Jinyin, Zhang Yan, Zhang Xuhong, Ge Chunpeng, Liu Zhe, Ouyang Yike, Ji Shouling. Survey of Adversarial Attack, Defense and Robustness Analysis for Natural Language Processing[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2021, 58(8): 1727-1750. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2021.20210304
[8]	Pan Xudong, Zhang Mi, Yan Yifan, Lu Yifan, Yang Min. Evaluating Privacy Risks of Deep Learning Based General-Purpose Language Models[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2021, 58(5): 1092-1105. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2021.20200908
[9]	Bao Yang, Yang Zhibin, Yang Yongqiang, Xie Jian, Zhou Yong, Yue Tao, Huang Zhiqiu, Guo Peng. An Automated Approach to Generate SysML Models from Restricted Natural Language Requirements in Chinese[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2021, 58(4): 706-730. DOI: 10.7544/issn1000-1239.2021.20200757
[10]	Che Haiyan, Feng Tie, Zhang Jiachen, Chen Wei, and Li Dali. Automatic Knowledge Extraction from Chinese Natural Language Documents[J]. Journal of Computer Research and Development, 2013, 50(4): 834-842.

Cited By

Cited by

Periodical cited type(66)

1.	袁良志，海佳丽，汪润，邓文萍，肖勇，常凯. 知识图谱驱动的中医药标准数字化探索与实践. 中医药导报. 2025(01): 225-230 .
2.	范定容，王倩倩，沈奥，彭露. 从ChatGPT到Sora：人工智能在医学教育中的应用潜力与挑战. 中国医学教育技术. 2025(01): 33-40 .
3.	刘园园，王银刚. ChatGPT影响大学生判断能力：双向机理与对策. 湖北成人教育学院学报. 2025(01): 29-34 .
4.	魏昱，刘卫. 人工智能生成内容在服装设计中的应用现状. 毛纺科技. 2025(01): 134-142 .
5.	李冰，鲜勇，雷刚，苏娟. ChatGPT架构下课程智能教学助手建设探讨. 教育教学论坛. 2025(03): 45-48 .
6.	梁炜，许振宇. 大语言模型赋能舆情治理现代化：价值、风险与路径. 中国应急管理科学. 2025(01): 93-103 .
7.	刘邦奇，聂小林，王士进，袁婷婷，朱洪军，赵子琪，朱广袤. 生成式人工智能与未来教育形态重塑：技术框架、能力特征及应用趋势. 电化教育研究. 2024(01): 13-20 .
8.	秦涛，杜尚恒，常元元，王晨旭. ChatGPT的工作原理、关键技术及未来发展趋势. 西安交通大学学报. 2024(01): 1-12 .
9.	张小朝. AIGC在商旅行业中的应用探索. 广东通信技术. 2024(01): 75-79 .
10.	廉霄兴，宋勇，朱军，王淑玲，叶晓舟，欧阳晔. 基于双通道理论的通信认知增强技术研究. 电信科学. 2024(01): 123-135 .
11.	杨永恒. 人工智能时代社会科学研究的“变”与“不变”. 人民论坛·学术前沿. 2024(04): 96-105 .
12.	刘英祥，张琳. 生成式人工智能技术在海事管理工作中的应用探索. 航海. 2024(02): 62-64 .
13.	吕静，何平，王永芬，冉朝霞，曹钦兴，古文帆，彭敏，田敏. ChatGPT在医学领域研究态势的文献计量学分析. 医学与哲学. 2024(07): 30-35 .
14.	王益君，董韵美. 公众对人工智能的认知与情感态度——以ChatGPT为例. 知识管理论坛. 2024(01): 16-29 .
15.	陈雷. ChatGPT在公安院校教育教学中的应用及影响. 太原城市职业技术学院学报. 2024(02): 85-88 .
16.	尤冲，李彦兵. 基于ChatGPT大语言模型应用的公共体育服务智能化:指征、风险及其规制. 南京体育学院学报. 2024(02): 1-12 .
17.	杨胜钦. 从ChatGPT看AI对电信网络诈骗犯罪治理的影响. 犯罪与改造研究. 2024(05): 26-33 .
18.	王春英，姚亚妮，滕白莹. 生成式人工智能嵌入敏捷政府建设：影响、风险与应对. 北京行政学院学报. 2024(03): 73-83 .
19.	王雯，李永智. 国际生成式人工智能教育应用与省思. 开放教育研究. 2024(03): 37-44 .
20.	张智义. 体认语言学视阈下ChatGPT语言生成及性能研究. 外语研究. 2024(03): 20-25+43+112 .
21.	余淑珍，单俊豪，闫寒冰. 情感计算赋能个性化教学：逻辑框架、问题解构与多元重塑. 现代远距离教育. 2024(02): 53-61 .
22.	高尚. 大语言模型与中台：共融还是替代？. 科技与金融. 2024(05): 59-62 .
23.	郭亚军，马慧芳，张鑫迪，冯思倩. ChatGPT赋能图书馆知识服务：原理、场景与进路. 图书馆建设. 2024(03): 60-68 .
24.	高雪松，黄蕴华，王斌. 基于专利数据的生成式人工智能技术栈创新态势研究. 东北财经大学学报. 2024(04): 53-61 .
25.	张渊. ChatGPT文本的生成机制与文本特性分析. 重庆文理学院学报(社会科学版). 2024(04): 105-114 .
26.	罗仕鉴，于慧伶，易珮琦. 数智时代工业设计知识生产新范式. 机械设计. 2024(08): 6-10 .
27.	徐炳文. 基于ChatGPT的人工智能交互技术工业物联网平台研究. 工业控制计算机. 2024(08): 132-134 .
28.	Deyi Li，Jialun Yin，Tianlei Zhang，Wei Han，Hong Bao. The Four Most Basic Elements In Machine Cognition. Data Intelligence. 2024(02): 297-319 .
29.	黄语，刘海洋，常海军，杨远松. 基于ChatGPT工作模式的AI工具在BIM技术中的潜在应用与实现途径. 科技创新与应用. 2024(26): 181-184+188 .
30.	李琳娜，丁楷，韩红旗，王力，李艾丹. 基于知识图谱的中文科技文献问答系统构建研究. 中国科技资源导刊. 2024(04): 51-62 .
31.	裴炳森，李欣，蒋章涛，刘明帅. 基于大语言模型的公安专业小样本知识抽取方法研究. 计算机科学与探索. 2024(10): 2630-2642 .
32.	李克寒，余丽媛，邵企能，蒋可，乌丹旦. 大语言模型在口腔住院医师规范化培训中的应用构想. 中国卫生产业. 2024(07): 155-158 .
33.	钟厚涛. 生成式人工智能给翻译实践带来的机遇与挑战. 北京翻译. 2024(00): 238-250 .
34.	张夏恒，马妍. AIGC在应急情报服务中的应用研究. 图书馆工作与研究. 2024(11): 60-67 .
35.	崔金满，李冬梅，田萱，孟湘皓，杨宇，崔晓晖. 提示学习研究综述. 计算机工程与应用. 2024(23): 1-27 .
36.	周代数，魏杉汀. 人工智能驱动的科学研究第五范式：演进、机制与影响. 中国科技论坛. 2024(12): 97-107 .
37.	钱力，张智雄，伍大勇，常志军，于倩倩，胡懋地，刘熠. 科技文献大模型:方法、框架与应用. 中国图书馆学报. 2024(06): 45-58 .
38.	潘崇佩，廖康启，孔勇发. 生成式人工智能背景下的近代物理实验教学改革. 实验室研究与探索. 2024(12): 117-122 .
39.	李德毅，刘玉超，殷嘉伦. 认知机器如何创造. 中国基础科学. 2024(06): 1-11 .
40.	李德毅，张天雷，韩威，海丹，鲍泓，高洪波. 认知机器的结构和激活. 智能系统学报. 2024(06): 1604-1613 .
41.	蔡昌，庞思诚. ChatGPT的智能性及其在财税领域的应用. 商业会计. 2023(09): 41-46 .
42.	于书娟，卢小雪，赵磊磊. 教育人工智能变革的基本逻辑与发展进路. 当代教育科学. 2023(05): 40-49 .
43.	曹克亮. ChatGPT：意识形态家的机器学转向及后果. 统一战线学研究. 2023(04): 134-144 .
44.	宋恺，屈蕾蕾，杨萌科. 生成式人工智能的治理策略研究. 信息通信技术与政策. 2023(07): 83-88 .
45.	陈凌云，姚宽达，王茜，方安，李刚. ChatGPT:研究进展、模型创新及医学信息研究应用场景优化. 医学信息学杂志. 2023(07): 18-23+29 .
46.	彭强，李羿卫. 自然用户界面在智能家居系统中的应用路径创新研究：生成式人工智能技术的调节作用. 包装工程. 2023(16): 454-463 .
47.	杨军农，王少波. 类ChatGPT技术嵌入政务服务网的应用场景、风险隐患与实施建议. 信息与电脑(理论版). 2023(10): 183-186 .
48.	政光景，吕鹏. 生成式人工智能与哲学社会科学新范式的涌现. 江海学刊. 2023(04): 132-142+256 .
49.	吴梦妮. 社交媒体传播视域下玩具企业应用AI技术实施营销的实践路径. 玩具世界. 2023(04): 144-146 .
50.	李德毅，殷嘉伦，张天雷，韩威，鲍泓. 机器认知四要素说. 中国基础科学. 2023(03): 1-10+22 .
51.	王洁. ChatGPT对知识服务的五大变革. 图书馆. 2023(09): 10-16 .
52.	刘乃嘉. 基于ChatGPT的矿山工程风险评估预警系统实现探讨. 企业科技与发展. 2023(08): 44-47 .
53.	裴炳森，李欣，吴越. 基于ChatGPT的电信诈骗案件类型影响力评估. 计算机科学与探索. 2023(10): 2413-2425 .
54.	张新新，丁靖佳. 生成式智能出版的技术原理与流程革新. 图书情报知识. 2023(05): 68-76 .
55.	张新新，黄如花. 生成式智能出版的应用场景、风险挑战与调治路径. 图书情报知识. 2023(05): 77-86+27 .
56.	陈靖. ChatGPT的类人想象与安全风险分析. 网络空间安全. 2023(04): 8-12 .
57.	李佩芳，陈佳丽，宁宁，王立群，张涵旎. ChatGPT在医学领域的应用进展及思考. 华西医学. 2023(10): 1456-1460 .
58.	朱敏锐，郜云帆，黄勇. 以新时代优良学风涵养新时代外语人才. 北京教育(高教). 2023(11): 35-37 .
59.	丁红菊. 消解与重构：人工智能技术对新闻业的影响——基于对ChatGPT的研究. 运城学院学报. 2023(05): 57-62 .
60.	李钥，淮盼盼，杨辉. ChatGPT在护理教育中的应用状况及优劣分析. 护理学杂志. 2023(21): 117-121 .
61.	张绍龙. 基于ChatGPT的人工智能技术应用. 集成电路应用. 2023(11): 200-201 .
62.	崔克克，孙冲，李辉，赵凌飞. 浅谈水泥企业数字化转型发展. 中国水泥. 2023(12): 28-33 .
63.	单琳，王文娟，刘舒萌. ChatGPT在医学分子生物学教学中的应用. 基础医学教育. 2023(12): 1084-1086 .
64.	李德毅，刘玉超，任璐. 人工智能看智慧. 科学与社会. 2023(04): 131-149 .
65.	付翔，魏晓伟，张浩，徐宁. 数字安全角度下审视和剖析ChatGPT. 航空兵器. 2023(06): 117-122 .
66.	黄婷，刘力凯. 基于大模型的数智化语言教学探索与应用. 连云港职业技术学院学报. 2023(04): 73-79 .